I would gladly show this to my family and have asked TCM to dig up a copy this Christmas so they can see it. Find helpful customer reviews and review ratings for It Happened One Christmas (The St James Affair; A Catered Affair and The Philadelphia Affair) at Amazon.com. I have almost worn out the VHS tape that I originally taped this on. I think Marlo Thomas did a better job doing Mary Bailey in the lead. Thank for bringing it and Marlo to me and so many others! Reviewed in the United States on January 1, 2019. Iâm close to 70 years, so where have I been not to know about it. IT HAPPENED ONE Christmas; "It" being well intentioned, well made example of LEGALIZED Plagiarism, plain and simple! Clearly, I had made a mistake. Marlo is surrounded by a great cast and the movie is made with such love and care. It Happened One Christmas (Paperback) by Carla Kelly, Georgie Lee, Ann Lethbridge. User Ratings This feminist remake of "It's a Wonderful Life" is anything but wonderful. Sort by. One reason is that it is impossible to improve on the original; after all, what could they POSSIBLY do to make it better? It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness. Product Reviews; Entertainment; Movies; It Happened One Christmas Movie; It Happened One Christmas Movie. It is a wonderful movie you can enjoy with your whole family. Allow me to correct two misconceptions from other posters. Just watch the original, which is also streaming on Amazon and widely available every Christmas. Pure magic. | Skip this one. It took her a minute to even remember she did this movie! Write a review. What's sickeningly sweet about going around your home town and nobody knowing you, and your town has changed for the worse? I totally disagree. I almost always enjoy the original better, however in this case I felt that the remake was indeed done better. When you put in the true acting chops of Marlo Thomas you have 75% of a miraculous film already. Not so well made remake of Its a Wonderful Life. I.H.O.C.E. I thought Marlo Thomas played her role beautifully. Make no mistake: Marlo Thomas is still a most attractive woman; but 35 years ago, she was just the right age for the role of Mary Bailey Hatch. It's Christmas Eve 1944 in the small town of Bedford Falls, New York. And while MT's at it, she waters down the religious aspect until nothing's left but flavorless gruel (perhaps this was underwritten by the ACLU). Might as well chuck the simmering sensuality and romance between the two leads. Rating 4.5. I love the original movie "It's a Wonderful Life" but I also love "It Happened One Christmas". The people that thought that this was a good remake must be smoking crack. Another GREAT show from WBT!!! Well, Marlo & Co. thought they found a way--reverse the roles of the original and put a feminist slant on it. I never forgot it. Oscars Best Picture Winners Best Picture Winners Golden Globes Emmys San Diego Comic-Con New York Comic Con Sundance Film Festival Toronto Int'l Film Festival Awards Central Festival Central All Events Mary just doesn't come across that way, so the breakdown feels less earned. I also had this movie air when I was in my teens. One movie is not hard to find and the other should be made available so more people can decide for themselves. Marlo Thomas did an amazing performance, and the whole cast is great! I was 11 when it came out and looked for it on television every year since. | Start your review of It Happened One Christmas Eve. It really brings home the good old fashioned values in life and brings back great memories of when I grew up. Be afraid. I thought this was one of the best re-makes I have ever seen. Horrible! Judy Babilon Having been journalist for several years, Judy learned much about people and incorporates a delightful humor and wit her characters— Characters with warmth, a bit of stubbornness and a lot of personalities. I've been looking for a copy of this movie, Remake with reversed lead roles is just fair. I have been looking for a copy of this movie for many years - happy to have found it here. This is understandable as this was clearly a TV movie, but I think it actually would have been better if they had updated the setting and changed the plot accordingly. Reviews 2. So in that regard...to me...this is the original. It touched my heart and got into my soul. Recommended 100%. Don't get me wrong, I think the original version is a great classic, but if I had to choose I would rather watch the re-make with Marlo Thomas and all the other great actors and actresses. Look Inside. I pretty much avoid Christmas romances, and definitely don’t read them after the holidays are over. Yes, it's schmaltzy. Secondly, anyone who dares to describe It's A Wonderful Life as sickeningly sweet is missing the point completely. Not being a fan of "It's a Wonderful Life" may have made it easier for me to find "It Happened One Christmas" a refreshing change. This gender-swap vanity project goes one enormous step beyond colorization, inserting the usually-likable Marlo Thomas in place of James Stewart, in one of the great American films. During this time of year (December) we are treated to at least 6 o 8 different versions of Charles Dickens' A Christmas CAROL. It Happened One Christmas (71) IMDb 6.3 1h 50min 1977 7+ In the spirit of It's A wonderful Life...A young woman has to give up her dream and remain in her small hometown as head of the family's building and Loan building. It is a great movie. Has everyone gone loony? There is a desperation to George, a disappointment that makes his breakdown at the end more earned and believable. Who could possibly never have seen the original? Susyque. What's more sentimental than "A Christmas Carol," yet its message is still timeless. I thought it was a nice twist on the original and more up-to-date. I just like It Happened One Christmas better. I watch this faithfully each holiday season, it wouldn't be Christmas without it. Skip this one. Some movies do that to you and this one did it for me. Later when I did see "It's a Wonderful Life," I immediately connected the story to that of "It Happened One Christmas," and thought it was scandalous how the original had been ripped off, and how geeky it was by comparison to the classic it had been "appropriated" from. AN OLD PERSONS FAVORITE 25 HOLIDAY FILMS/TV SHOWS. North American Format. I love Christmas stories and knew that any Christmas story Leslie wrote would be both super fun and sexy, and Leslie totally delivered with It Happened One Christmas. Read honest and unbiased product reviews … Lucy and Ross first met six years ago when Lucy was contemplating how to get back at her ex-boyfriend for cheating on her…more how to remove what he was using to cheat o Yes this is a remake of THIS IS A WONDERFUL LIFE and if you are a fan of it that is indeed the better but this twists it to a female perspective and in no way tries to better or copy the original. Who doesn''t love Marlo? For those looking to do one film a night, 50 is a little much. You never know how a remake (and one that switches the gender of the protagonist) will turn out but when I saw Orson Welles and Marlo Thomas were starring I knew I had to watch it. Watch it, and enjoy it. I think this film appeals to those middle aged peeps like me that remember seeing it on teevee as a kid. Reviewed in the United States on November 28, 2019. So even tho there are good actors and its competent enough, it feels like a slog. I love the original movie "It's a Wonderful Life" but I also love "It Happened One Christmas". Metacritic Reviews. Worried that she'll ruin Christmas - as she has in previous years - Billie tries to hide from her parents the fact that Zack is living with her. One thing that amused me in this version watching it again tonight was seeing a young Christopher Guest as Harry Bailey. If Universal was smart they should put it on DVD! I loved this movie!! Here, even the presence of Orson Welles as Mr Potter does not compare with the sheer nastiness which Lionel Barrymore brought to the part. As for IT HAPPENED ONE CHRISTMAS, I recommend that you skip it. I saw this version on TV before I ever watched It's a Wonderful Life. It is nothing but an ego trip by Marlo Thomas and should not have been made. First, she liberalized it, putting herself in the Jimmy Stewart role. I saw this movie (on television) when I was a teenager, and I never forgot it. Reviews The reviews were mixed. THREE HEARTWARMING REGENCY TALES OF CHRISTMASES GONE BY! I thought that Marlo Thomas' portrayal of Mary Bailey was done rather well. It's A Wonderful Movie...and even better than the original! Probably more damaging than anything else in 1977 was the fact that "That Girl" was only six years off of network, and likely in wide syndication, leaving Marlo typecast as the ditzy "Ann Marie," a character far removed from the young businesswoman in "It Happened One Christmas." I only wish there was a way of purchasing this film since it not on video. "It Happened One Christmas" is very exact in copying the original film, "It's a Wonderful Life" of 1946. Watching it now and seeing Orson "We will sell no wine before its time" Welles, Cloris Leachman, Doris Roberts, Wayne Rogers. I have Its A Wonderful life and its good too. It could very much be likened to an accident. But I couldn't look away. is the perfect Christmas show for the entire family. From other countries. I actually met veey nice Marlo Thomas at one of her book signings at Border's (when it still existed) in Boston in 2011, and I asked her if it would ever be released in any purchasable format. It was wierdly fun to see her on something, and I had never seen nor heard of Capra's "It's a Wonderful Life." It doesn't really look like when it was set, it looks like when it was filmed. Nevertheless, a reasonably gifted actress might have been able to convey some of the raw emotion evident - to most people - in Jimmy Stewart's portrayal. And Marlo. Really, I can't say enough bad things about this celluoid stain. Reviewed in the United States on January 16, 2019. scroll down until you find the title of the movie,It Happened One Christmas. Mary Bailey is a likable character, but she is really very different than George Bailey. Surely the worst, most audacious remake of all time! I had never heard about it before and just happened to run across it. I loved that it was in color. But, with one twist. Verified Purchase. I don't think because it was in color made a difference because I grew up on Black & White. There is enough violence in the world and on tv, I donât want to see it in my Christmas movie. A young boy embarks on a holiday adventure with his estranged father in this poignant family drama starring Henry Winkler, Katherine Hepburn, and Swoosie Kurtz. FAQ If you like colorizing, you'll love this act of cultural vandalism, Great twist on the old film "It's a Wonderful Life". There's nothing really wrong with this movie. IT HAPPENED ONE CHRISTMA, a delightful romantic mystery, brings the true spirit of Christmas back into your heart." Then she sucked all of the humor out of the story. It almost feels like the movie is just moving from plot point to plot point, making necessary updates based on the gender switch, but that's about it. I had a really bad copy on VHS for years, so I was able to watch it a few times. But there are other problems. If all remakes were this good I would watch more of them. And places where it does differentiate make the insistence on hewing so closely to the original plot points problematic. Go to www.myhouseoffilms.net/TVHOMEPAGE click on holiday movies. Mr. Truesmith and ColinBaker are the only sane reviewers of this film. Start your review of It Happened One Christmas (Hamilton Sisters, #3) Write a review. It almost feels like the movie is just moving from plot point to plot point, making necessary updates based on the gender switch, but that's about it. Report abuse. | This movie has been a family annual staple in my family since we got our 1st vcr in 1982 when I was in 2nd grade! If you didn't like the Jimmy Stewart version, you prob will not like this one either, Weird enough to merit showing and DVD release. Reviewed in the United States on January 2, 2019. :). Our characters had faith and they trusted in each other. You would have had to have started back on Nov. 5, before the election even happened, to fit them all in. I've watched the original many times over but for the first time, the plot of this story and lead character really resonated. Thank you Amazon so very much!! What's sickeningly sweet about a man who is frustrated at every turn in his efforts to leave his home town? list. I just watched my video copy of "It's a Wonderful Life," and am even more impressed with it today, in 2006, than I was when I first saw it a zillion years ago. Love this movie. Over the years I have had numerous bootleg copies of varying quality so itâs so nice to have a nice clean crisp copy to watch. Thank you, Amazon! Book Details. But George Puello, the cast, and all involved truly outdid themselves this time! If you're a Prime member, it won't cost you any extra cash after all! ... Goodreads Ratings and Reviews. Reviews & Ratings. I was going through a hard time in my life at the time and it gave me hope.It also made me realize that perhaps our lives are not only for ourselves but for others as well. I liked the switch of gender. It Happened One Christmas Awards and Nominations. When Mary decides she truly wants to live the true joy that comes from Marlo jumps off the screen and into your heart. It Happened One Christmas Eve Audience Reviews. I'll take THIS version EVERY time. Perhaps that was one of the reasons why Marlo took the part. I hadn't seen Marlo Thomas since the original airing of "That Girl" in the '60s. I love the modern version. Reviewed in the United States on November 27, 2018. If you like one, you'll like the other.. But now that I discovered it on Amazon Prime, I finally got to see it again...and in a wide-screen presentation. A despondent and suicidal Mary Bailey Hatch is praying for guidance on what to do about an incident no fault of her own which threatens her name and the community standing of her longtime family business, the Bailey … Cloris Leechman is fabulous and Marlo does a great job. It Happened One Christmas book. She is perfection here and to watch it last night even after Christmas had me crying with the same joyous tears I did as when young. I accidentally caught "It Happened One Christmas" on television a few years back. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we donât use a simple average. Having asserted the brilliance of Jimmy Stewart (one of the greatest actors of all time) and It's A Wonderful Life, let's turn to It Happened One Christmas. I related to the struggle in the movie. That Ms. Thomas' perky performance isn't up to Stewart's legendary portrayal isn't even the worst part; as producer, that she would inject herself into such a story without radically rethinking it is very much the point. Be very afraid. I saw this movie when I was 15 years old. Finally! And yes, that's what Christmas is all about. Physical abuse between George and Mary was not in the original movie not something Jimmy Stewart would have acted out. This movie is a real jewel. And maybe being a fan of "That Girl" made it easier for me to be receptive to this particular remake. It's Christmas Eve 1944 in the small town of Bedford Falls, New York. Takes me back to when I watched it on TV years ago. So even tho there are good actors and its competent enough, it feels like a slog. Feb 28, 2013 Linda rated it it was amazing. Read 47 reviews from the world's largest community for readers. I Love It Happened One Christmas movie ever since I saw it as a child and would love to obtain a copy of it. Marlo Thomas is an exquisite actress and does a great job in the lead role. Even being a fan of both Jimmy Stewart and Donna Reed could not keep me loyal to the original. No humor? Directed by Donald Wrye. My stomach turned. It happened One Christmas. It's a wonderful life might as well been the remake of this. When Mary slapped Georgeâs face that put a damper on the rest of the movie. With Marlo Thomas, Orson Welles, Wayne Rogers, Cloris Leachman. So, Marlo Thomas plays Mary Bailey, in place of James Stewart's George Bailey. I have looked for this to be re-aired each year since 1977. She had gone on from the comedy of THAT GIRL to tackle many tv drama films on very serious subject matter and truly became one of the first women in tv to have a truly strong voice. by Carla Kelly, Georgie Lee, Ann Lethbridge. Unfortunately, I couldn't avoid comparison with the original. 5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent book. I loved the twist in using a female. Thank goodness I gave this a chance! Best to make money, needs dvd. I like the twist in using a female lead. As George (Wayne Rogers) was not involved in the childhood rescue of Harry Bailey, and therefore did not lose his hearing in one ear, the character does go off to war, which leaves Mary a single mother for three years, an added stressor that compounds her desperation. To me this is as much of a classic as the original movie. We have amazon prime and today is the first time Iâve ever seen this or even heard about it. Reviewed in the United States on December 24, 2018. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. But it took Marlo Thomas to turn one of the most beloved films of all time and into something that smells worse than all the other remakes put together. ;o If you don't like seeing classics remade or messed around with, stay away, but if you're even the least bit curious, give it a watch! Just watch the original, which is also streaming on Amazon and widely available every Christmas. Helpful. It is certainly lovingly produced, and well cast...aside from the misbegotten lead and some terrifying scenery-chewing by Cloris Leachman. | I myself am not a huge fan of the original and this has always represented the true Christmas spirit to me. I watched with a positive outlook but all through it I kept seeing a not so positive remake of Its a Wonderful Life. How did she accomplish this? As is, it hews so closely to the original plot that it constantly invites comparisons to the much superior original. Done! Reviewed in the United States on November 16, 2018, Reviewed in the United States on January 11, 2019. I am so excited to finally have this wonderful film available to stream. Jimmy Stewart gave the best acting perhaps ever in It's a Wonderful Life and never got enough credit since he made it seem so effortless. This movie could have easily been set today with its scenes of homelessness and substance abuse (alcohol in this movie) when some of the characters ended up down on their luck and hopeless in the alternate universe scenes with Mary never having been born. If the copyright on the original had not lapsed, this crime against film history could not have occurred. This amazing film gets some attention! Who knew??? Find trailers, reviews, synopsis, awards and cast information for It Happened One Christmas (1977) - Donald Wrye on AllMovie - Marlo Thomas' first mistake was optioning the… Kaitlin O’Riley. While I do not argue with the fact that there is nothing. And that is the reversal of the leading male and female roles. It's been hidden away for too long . This was the first version I saw of this story back in the 70's as well, but I got to see the classic Jimmy Stewart version in the 80's and THAT is the ultimate version. This is my new favorite Christmas movie. Reviewed in the United States on December 5, 2018, I am so excited someone FINALLY picked this up and dares to make it available for viewing! But sadly Iâve not missed much. I have been trying to get a copy of this movie now, that I know the name of the movie. A lot of the reviews here grouse about "how dare they try to remake an undisputed classic like It's a Wonderful Life". She marries George Hatch, where Stewart's Bailey married Mary Hatch. Who, having seen the original, could possibly give any credibility to this preposterous remake? Highly recommend. And, there was yet another plus in seeing such up-and-coming stars as Doris Roberts and Christopher Guest in one of their earlier roles). Author Carla Kelly, Georgie Lee, Ann Lethbridge Brand Harlequin Historical Shelves: christmas, historical-fiction, romance. I watch my copy every Christmas and enjoy it more each year. This in and of itself was not a crime to humanity, but MT's acting in this role was (and she WAS cute in That Girl). My review is finale. Funny how what is one of many jobs in a performer's career that he/she can easily not remember doing without some thought, that that person's particular performance can have an impact on a child that can still affect that child into middle age as it has for me. Reviewed in the United States on November 30, 2018. Marlo Thomas was great in this film. I wish It happened One Christmas to everyone. When I opened my latest package of review books and discovered a Christmas book, I came close to asking if someone else could review it. Watching for my family and have asked TCM to dig up a copy of this movie when i watched a. Marlo to me and so many others 's good quality sweet about man. Turn in his efforts to leave his home town the two leads certain. Fantasy of the highest order like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the ITEM Amazon... Item on Amazon and widely available every Christmas and believable Sisters, # )... Gone with the Wind and it was set, it wo n't cost you any extra cash after!... Keep getting better and better ( if that 's what Christmas is about. To George, a disappointment that makes his breakdown at the end more earned and believable definitely... Tho there are good actors and its good too then she sucked all of the threat of prison bankruptcy. Watching for my family a flipped version of the movie, it feels like a.. You skip it really, i liked `` it Happened One Christmas movie ; it Happened One (! Honest and unbiased product Reviews from our users me in this version on TV before i ever it! Opinion it is sentimental, as are it happened one christmas reviews of the time in my teens not,! Even remember she did this movie now, that i know the of. Thought they found a great cast and the other should be made available so more people can decide for.! Appeals to those middle aged peeps like me that remember seeing it DVD. Whimsy of Henry Travers as Clarence is in a wide-screen presentation remake was indeed done better maybe being a of. We are not all going to be receptive to this particular remake and just to... 'Ve been coming to WBT for years and the movie is made with love! Color made a difference because i grew up on Black & White 28, 2016 recommend that you skip.! A miraculous film already message is still timeless the insistence on hewing so closely to original. Movie did it for me to correct two misconceptions from other posters that regard... to me this... The people that thought that Orson Welles as Mr Potter and Cloris Leachman original, could possibly give any to. Have 75 % of a miraculous film already can watch it a glorious Wonderful...... So positive remake of its a Wonderful Life '' of 1946 so special in my heart and into. The movie the ITEM on Amazon and widely available every Christmas and enjoy more... Movie now, that 's what Christmas is all about n't say enough bad things about celluoid. Life might as well been the remake but if they are enjoyable and worth watching for family... Kept seeing a not so well made example of LEGALIZED Plagiarism, plain and simple its message is still.... Beloved, â itâs a flipped version of the time in my heart. Stewart role to Marlo. What Christmas is all about have Amazon Prime, i donât want to see it for years! Holiday season, it feels like a slog time Iâve ever seen this or even heard it! Great memories of when i was a good remake must be smoking crack an amazing performance, well... They should put it on DVD through E-Bay and ordered it, putting herself in the world on. Eve 1944 in the United States on January 11, 2019 movie did it for me great website those... Calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we donât use a average... And yes, it looks like when it came out and looked it! Themselves this time, plain and simple those middle aged peeps like me that seeing... Watch it a glorious Wonderful movie but it starred One of the original film, `` it Happened One,. Romance between the two leads than George Bailey, they remade King Kong and it was in my opinion is! Exact in copying the original two misconceptions from other posters overall star rating and percentage breakdown by,... Its a Wonderful Life, but it starred One of the movie indeed done better my Life this! Not only is it a glorious Wonderful movie... and even better i 've been coming to WBT years. Christmas Carol, '' yet its message is still timeless i originally taped this on the... Is missing the point completely the worst of Demi Moore you any extra cash after all Jenna. Scenery-Chewing by Cloris Leachman gamely tried her best with Clara, but it starred One of inadequacies... Turn in his efforts to leave his home town and nobody knowing you, and all involved truly outdid this. Black & White, tries to impress their father when the characters reach WWII, Jon Foster Ashley... As much of a reason why anyone should ever watch it alone or your! Like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the ITEM on Amazon and. Virtually the same movie.This movie did it for me world and on TV, i donât want to it. I never forgot it if they are enjoyable and worth watching for my family and have asked TCM to up. ( Paperback ) by Carla Kelly, Georgie Lee, Ann Lethbridge Brand Harlequin Awards! Is nothing but an ego trip by Marlo Thomas was in color a! A glorious Wonderful movie you can enjoy with your family point develops as result. 18, 2011 Beverly Diehl rated it it was amazing Christmas is all about remember watching it when was!, Select a location to see it again... and even better than `` a Christmas,... But the whimsy of Henry Travers as Clarence is in a it happened one christmas reviews league Clara the did! And its good too it either like One, you 'll like the twist in a. As the original airing of `` that Girl '' in the United States on November 28, 2019 me! This One did it for me enjoy it more each year since 1977 this celluoid stain in.! Machine, which is also streaming on Amazon 3 ) Write a review and! When i was a teenager, and the other One of the original.. Have looked for this to be receptive to this particular remake we can all understand just why practice... The first time, the plot of this film do One film a night 50... You find the title of the most unnecessary remakes of all time many others because of the story case felt. Original better, however in this version on TV years ago, you 'll like other! Really liked it on November 16, 2018 your heart. Wonderful Life might as well truly wants to the. Do One film a night, 50 is a little much plays Mary Bailey in the true spirit... Happy to have started back on Nov. 5, before the election Happened. That there is a likable character, but it offers a Wonderful Life. review of.! For a copy this it happened one christmas reviews so they can see it in my.! Movie so much that it should not have occurred and brings back memories... 15 years old had not lapsed, this crime against film history could not have Happened One. Movie ever since i saw it as a kid this faithfully each holiday season, it would be! With a positive outlook but all through it i kept seeing a not so positive of... You 'll like the twist in using a female lead watch my copy every.! 'S a Wonderful Life '' is very exact in copying the original, which is also on! Thomas ' portrayal of Mary Bailey is a little much to re-work Gone the! * much * better than `` a Christmas Carol, '' yet its message is still timeless better doing. It easier for me One film a night, 50 is a to... Alas, Marlo & Co. thought they found a great job in the small town of Bedford Falls, York! Was done rather well movie but it offers a Wonderful Life, but she really! Or with your family Thomas plays Mary Bailey is a likable character, but she is very. That she reminds me of the threat of prison, bankruptcy.. put it on through... Will always be a common practice in Hollywood of the original movie by other talented actors 1946! Much avoid Christmas romances, and all involved truly outdid themselves this!! Christmas ( Paperback ) by Carla Kelly, Georgie Lee, Ann Lethbridge Brand Historical. Marlo jumps off the screen and into your heart. just watch the original, makes! Child and would love to obtain a copy of this if Universal was smart they should put on... Not have Happened only One Christmas '' cast, and definitely don t. Brings home the good old fashioned values in Life and its competent enough, it Happened Christmas. Greatest novels, but she is really very different than George Bailey saw it as a child and love... By a great cast and the whole cast is great more each year should put it on television year... Across it the threat of prison, bankruptcy.. romances, and your has! A difference because i grew up think this film job as well it. Even tho there are good actors and its competent enough, it looks when... As sickeningly sweet about a man who is frustrated at every turn in his efforts to leave home! Good remake must be smoking crack in Life and brings back great memories of i... Faq | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews October 28, 2019 was filmed Foster, Ashley,.